Minnesota Theft and Robbery Defense Attorney

It may begin with a store employee asking you to step into a back room. Or with police officers arriving after an argument over money, property, or something that allegedly went missing. Then the questions start. What began as a confusing or heated moment can quickly turn into a criminal case carrying the risk of jail, fines, restitution, and a lasting record. 

At Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell, and Erickson, we represent people facing theft and robbery charges in Minnesota. We take the time to understand what happened, examine the evidence, and help clients prepare for the road ahead. 

Contact UsAll Services

Theft and Robbery Are Not the Same Charge 

Theft and robbery both involve allegations of taking property, but the difference between them is significant. 

Theft generally involves taking, using, keeping, transferring, or concealing property without the owner’s consent and with the required intent. Minnesota’s theft statute also covers conduct beyond physically taking an item, including certain allegations involving services, lost property, leased property, business funds, motor vehicles, and other forms of financial loss. 

Robbery involves taking property from a person, or in that person’s presence, while using or threatening the immediate use of force. In other words, robbery is not simply theft of something valuable. The allegation of force or intimidation is what changes the nature of the charge. 

Think of it this way: quietly taking a wallet left on a counter may lead to a theft allegation. Taking a wallet while pushing its owner away may lead to a robbery charge. 

That distinction can mean the difference between a misdemeanor case and a serious felony. 

Theft Charges Can Arise in Many Ways 

When people hear “theft,” they often picture shoplifting. Minnesota law covers a much broader range of conduct. 

A person may face theft-related allegations involving: 

  • Shoplifting or retail theft 
  • Taking money or property from an employer 
  • Keeping property found or delivered by mistake 
  • Using another person’s property without permission 
  • Failing to return leased or rented property 
  • Taking services without paying 
  • Unauthorized use of a motor vehicle 
  • Misusing business or client funds 
  • Receiving or possessing stolen property 
  • Taking merchandise during an emergency or civil disturbance 
  • Using devices intended to defeat store security systems 

Someone does not necessarily have to be caught carrying an item out of a store. A theft case may be built around video, receipts, account records, employee statements, text messages, or assumptions about who had access to property.

Theft Penalties Depend on More Than Price 

The value of the property or services is often important, but it is not the only factor that determines the charge. 

Under Minnesota law, theft of property or services worth $500 or less is generally punishable by up to 90 days in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. Theft involving more than $500 but no more than $1,000 can generally carry up to 364 days in jail and a fine of up to $3,000. 

Theft involving more than $1,000 but no more than $5,000 can carry up to five years in prison and a $10,000 fine. Theft involving more than $5,000 may carry up to 10 years in prison and a $20,000 fine. Certain thefts involving more than $35,000, firearms, trade secrets, or particular forms of business misconduct may carry even greater penalties. 

The charge may also be elevated based on the type of property, how it was taken, or the accused person’s prior record. 

That means a lower-dollar allegation is not always a minor case, and a theft does not have to involve thousands of dollars to become a felony. 

Receiving Stolen Property Can Also Lead to Charges 

You do not have to be accused of personally stealing an item to face a theft-related prosecution. 

Minnesota law makes it a crime to receive, possess, transfer, buy, or conceal stolen property when a person knows—or has reason to know—that the property was stolen or obtained through robbery. The possible sentence generally follows the same penalty structure used for theft. 

These cases often raise difficult questions. 

Was the purchase price unusually low? Did the seller give a believable explanation? Were serial numbers removed? Was the property mixed in with someone else’s belongings? Did the accused person actually know where it came from? 

Possession alone may not tell the full story. The state must still prove the required knowledge or reason to know. 

Simple Robbery Is a Serious Felony 

Minnesota defines simple robbery as taking property from a person or in the person’s presence while using or threatening the immediate use of force to overcome resistance or compel the person to give up the property. 

A conviction can carry: 

  • Up to 10 years in prison 
  • A fine of up to $20,000 
  • Both prison and a fine 

The force does not always have to cause an injury. An allegation that someone pushed a store employee, grabbed a purse from a person’s hands, or threatened harm during a taking may be enough for prosecutors to consider a robbery charge. 

A situation that begins as suspected shoplifting can become much more serious when a confrontation occurs at the door.

What Is Aggravated Robbery? 

Aggravated robbery involves additional allegations that increase the seriousness of the offense. 

First-degree aggravated robbery may be charged when a person is allegedly armed with a dangerous weapon, uses an object in a way that makes the victim reasonably believe it is a dangerous weapon, or causes bodily harm during the robbery. 

A conviction for first-degree aggravated robbery can carry up to 20 years in prison and a fine of up to $35,000. 

An object does not necessarily have to be a real firearm to create this charge. A replica, concealed object, or ordinary item may become important if the state claims it was used to make someone reasonably believe a dangerous weapon was present. 

Second-degree aggravated robbery generally involves an alleged threat of bodily harm with an article used or presented in a way that implies it is a dangerous weapon. These cases also carry substantial felony exposure under Minnesota law. 

The Evidence May Be More Complicated Than It Appears 

The first police report is not always the full story. A witness may have seen only part of the event. Surveillance footage may be blurry or incomplete. Store inventory records may be inaccurate. Two people may have had access to the same property. A statement made during a stressful interrogation may be taken out of context. 

In a robbery case, the disagreement may center on whether force was used at all or whether it was connected to the alleged taking. 

A defense attorney may look at: 

  • Surveillance and body-camera footage 
  • Witness statements 
  • Receipts and transaction records 
  • Phone location data 
  • Text messages and social media communications 
  • Fingerprints or DNA evidence 
  • Property ownership and value 
  • Whether the accused person had permission 
  • Whether the state can prove intent 
  • Whether an identification procedure was reliable 
  • Whether a search or interrogation was lawful 

Sometimes one small detail changes the shape of the case. A timestamp, receipt, message, or second camera angle may show that events happened differently than the complaint suggests. 

Intent Is Often a Central Issue 

Theft is not always established simply because someone possessed property that belonged to another person. The prosecution may need to prove that the person acted with the intent required by the statute. That question can become especially important when property was borrowed, shared, abandoned, mistakenly taken, or involved in a dispute over ownership. 

For example, two former partners may disagree over who owns furniture, electronics, or a vehicle. An employee may believe they had permission to use company property. A shopper may leave a store without noticing that an item remained under a cart or inside a bag. 

Those explanations do not automatically defeat a charge, but they may matter when evaluating whether the state can prove criminal intent beyond a reasonable doubt. 

Possible Defenses to Theft and Robbery Charges 

The appropriate defense depends on the facts. Common issues may include: 

  • Lack of intent 
  • Mistaken identity 
  • Consent or permission 
  • A genuine claim of ownership 
  • Unreliable witness testimony 
  • Incorrect property valuation 
  • Lack of knowledge that property was stolen 
  • No use or threat of force 
  • An unlawful search or seizure 
  • An involuntary or improperly obtained statement 
  • Insufficient evidence 

In some cases, the goal may be dismissal or acquittal. In others, the most practical result may involve reducing the charge, limiting incarceration, seeking diversion when available, or protecting employment and licensing interests. 

A careful defense begins with understanding what the state can prove, not merely what it has alleged.

What Should You Do After an Arrest or Citation? 

The first instinct may be to explain everything immediately. That can create problems, especially when you do not yet know what evidence the police have collected. 

A more cautious approach can help: 

  • Do not discuss the facts with police without legal advice. 
  • Keep all citations, property receipts, and release documents. 
  • Save relevant messages, photographs, receipts, and records. 
  • Write down what happened while the details are fresh. 
  • Identify witnesses who may have useful information. 
  • Do not contact an alleged victim or witness in violation of an order. 
  • Avoid posting about the case online. 
  • Attend every court appearance. 
  • Speak with a Minnesota criminal defense attorney promptly. 

Trying to talk your way out of an accusation may feel natural. Unfortunately, statements made under pressure can be misunderstood or used against you later. 

How a Theft and Robbery Defense Attorney Can Help 

A Minnesota defense attorney can investigate the charge, review the state’s evidence, and explain the possible consequences in plain language. 

That work may include challenging identification evidence, disputing the value of property, reviewing surveillance recordings, examining how evidence was obtained, negotiating with prosecutors, and preparing for trial. 

Your attorney can also help address the practical concerns that come with a criminal case. Will a conviction affect your job? Is restitution being requested? Could a plea create immigration or licensing consequences? Is there a warrant or release condition that needs immediate attention? 

Those questions deserve answers before you make a decision that may follow you for years. 

Why Choose Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell, and Erickson? 

A theft or robbery accusation can make it feel as though the state has already decided who you are. We know that a charge is not the whole story. 

Our attorneys look closely at the facts, listen to our clients, and provide realistic guidance without exaggeration or empty promises. Whether the case involves a store accusation, disputed property, receiving stolen goods, or a serious robbery felony, we work to build a defense that reflects the evidence and the client’s priorities. 

Speak With a Minnesota Theft and Robbery Attorney 

Theft and robbery charges can put your freedom, employment, finances, and reputation at risk. The earlier the case is reviewed, the easier it may be to preserve evidence, locate witnesses, and avoid mistakes. You do not have to face the accusation based only on the police report’s version of events. 

Contact Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell, and Erickson to speak with a Minnesota theft and robbery defense attorney. We can review the allegations, explain the possible consequences, and help you take the next step with a clearer understanding of your options.

Recent Blogs

Why a Probate Attorney Matters When Managing an Estate
Why a Probate Attorney Matters When Managing an Estate

Managing an estate can sound simple at first. Find the assets, pay the bills, divide what’s left, and close everything out. That’s the basic idea, but the reality is usually more complicated. There may be court filings, unpaid debts, tax questions, property to sell,...

What Does a Family Law Attorney Do?
What Does a Family Law Attorney Do?

Picture this: It is late at night, the house is quiet, and you are staring at a message from your spouse that changes everything. Maybe the word “divorce” has finally been said out loud. Maybe you are worried about when you will see your children next. Or perhaps...

What Are the Penalties for DWI in Minnesota?
What Are the Penalties for DWI in Minnesota?

The flashing lights appear in your rearview mirror. Your stomach drops. A few minutes later, you’re standing beside the road, trying to follow an officer’s instructions while traffic rushes past and questions pile up in your head.  Will I lose my license? Am I going...

How to Find a Good Criminal Defense Attorney in Minnesota
How to Find a Good Criminal Defense Attorney in Minnesota

When you are facing a criminal charge, it can be hard to know what to do first. You may be thinking about court, work, your family, your reputation, or whether you could lose your license or freedom. On top of all that, you have to choose a lawyer.  That decision...

What Is a Felony Vs. Misdemeanor in Minnesota?
What Is a Felony Vs. Misdemeanor in Minnesota?

A criminal charge can change the tone of a day in an instant. Maybe it starts with a traffic stop. Maybe a disagreement gets out of hand. Maybe the police call, or a citation arrives, or someone you love is suddenly sitting in jail and nobody in the family knows what...

What Happens After A DWI Arrest in Minnesota? A Step-By-Step Guide
What Happens After A DWI Arrest in Minnesota? A Step-By-Step Guide

A DWI arrest can make everything feel like it is moving too fast. One moment, you are dealing with flashing lights in the rearview mirror. The next, you may be facing chemical testing, license issues, court dates, and questions you never expected to ask. Can you...

Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell
& Erickson, PLC
201 7th St W, Monticello, MN 55362
Fax: (763) 295-5165
Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson PLC Footer Logo

Smith Paulson O’Donnell & Erickson proudly serves clients in: Big Lake, Becker, Clear Lake, Albertville, Otsego, St. Michael, Buffalo, Monticello and more. We represent clients throughout Anoka County, Benton County, Hennepin County, Isanti County, Kanabec County, Mille Lacs County, Sherburne County, Stearns County and Wright County.

© 2026 Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Legal Website by PSM Marketing